I’ve eaten at most—though not all—of the restaurants in Tampa proper (and a bunch outside it). Ratings help, but the overall number can be misleading, you really have to dig into each review to figure out if you care about the things driving the rating (price, service, ambiance, a stuck-up maître d'). This list is about the most exceptional food and unique differentiators.
Bern’s Steak House — the full ritual (do it right)
What to know, fast: You’re here for the whole Bern’s experience: the themed rooms, the kitchen and wine tour, and the dessert room in those cozy wood wine cask booths with live piano. The steak is very good; the ritual is what makes it Bern’s.
- How to book: Reservations open on a rolling 60‑day window. Online reservations open at 8am (historically it was midnight). If you want a prime 7pm Friday/Saturday, set an alarm exactly 60 days out and jump on it the minute slots drop. Use the official Bern’s reservations page.
- How to “do” the night: Your server will offer the kitchen + cellar tour and dessert room after dinner—always say yes. If you have a dinner reservation, you don’t need a separate dessert reservation; dessert‑only tables (if you want just that) are a limited early window. See the dessert room note.
- Order like a local: Pick your steak and take what’s included—French onion soup, salad, baked potato, onion rings, and the vegetable. It’s plenty. Skip apps unless you want a lot of food. (Yes, that really is what’s included; it’s on the menu.)
- If you only care about the steak: Go to Charley’s—it’s the pure steak‑first play.
Columbia Restaurant — Florida history you can eat
Why this one: If you want Tampa’s story in one meal, this is the stop. The Ybor flagship opened in 1905 and the family now runs seven Columbia Restaurants across Florida—but Ybor is the mothership. Do one of these two: (a) Ybor flamenco dinner for the full show, or (b) the waterfront Columbia Café on the Riverwalk for views + museum stroll. Why not get the Columbia experience and a sunset or dance performance?
- Quick history hit: In 1935, Casimiro Hernandez Jr. went all‑in and built Tampa’s first air‑conditioned dining room—the Don Quixote Room—when that was a serious gamble. That bet helped cement Columbia as a city institution. (timeline)
- Order: Paella, sangria, and the 1905 Salad (tableside).
- Pro move: Choose Ybor if you want flamenco; choose the Riverwalk café for a breezy walk and the History Center next door.
Wright’s Gourmet House — the lunch you’ll think about tomorrow
Why this one: Big, carefully built sandwiches. Legendary cakes. Portions that travel. You’ll probably take half home.
- Quick history hit: Opened April 20, 1963 by Marjorie and Pete Wright; it started as a tiny gourmet shop and turned into a city habit. (Their story is on the Wright’s site.)
- Order: The Club (or Beef Martini faithfuls will lobby you), a slice of cake, and the Orange Spice iced tea—it’s a little Tampa traditio.
- How to do it: Go early or late lunch to dodge the line. Their catering is excellent if you’re feeding a group.
Osteria Natalina — tiny room, tastes like Italy (rare)
Why this one: Every city has “good” Italian. This actually eats like a great little place in Italy—simple, dialed‑in pastas, a small room, and a staff that cooks with care. That’s rare.
- House rules, short and sweet: No reservations. No kids. First‑come. The restaurant states a minimum age on its site; in practice, plan an adults‑only dinner.
- Order: Whatever pasta they’re excited about that night. Ask for a recommendation and go with it.
- How to do it: Show up at open to get on the list. If there’s a wait, grab a quick drink nearby.
Predalina — modern Mediterranean that just works
Why this one: Big, bright room; no weak spots. Great for mixed tastes, business dinners, or a celebratory night where you want to share a spread and everyone’s happy.
- Order: Steak frites and something with hummus to share; add a veg or two and call it. Browse the menu and order light—portions are generous.
- How to do it: Reserve for prime hours, then walk Water Street or the Riverwalk after.
Two more to know
Hale’s Blackbrick — chef‑driven Chinese, meant to share
Chef Richard Hales is a Tampa native who came home after years of cooking modern Chinese; the menu reads best family‑style. Truffle fried rice and sesame/Hong‑Shao Brussels sprouts are crowd‑pleasers; it’s not cheap, but it’s cooked with intent. Hales Blackbrick
Ponte Modern American — big‑night polish
I almost never say this, but get the bread: Parker House rolls with honey and black truffle butter—they’re limited and they sell out, so ask for them as soon as you sit down. Short ribs are excellent, and the room is built for celebrations. (IG post naming the rolls)
Quick routes (optional)
- Bern’s → dessert room, done.
- Ybor Columbia (flamenco) → stroll the brick streets.
- Predalina → Water Street/Riverwalk walk.
- Wright’s lunch → you’re set for later.
I hope you found this helpful. Drop your comments or questions below and sign up for my weekly newsletter.